1Best overall
American Home Shield
- Generous coverage caps
- Flexible service fees
- Covers unknown pre-existing issues
- Higher base premium
4.7
$29/mo
Comprehensive coverage
Best Home Warranty Companies
We compared coverage, pricing, and claim turnaround across 18 providers to find the warranties that deliver real peace of mind.
11 min readUpdated June 2026
2Best value
Choice Home Warranty
- Affordable plans
- Two simple plan options
- Fast claims
- Lower payout limits
4.4
$23/mo
Budget shoppers
3Best for add-ons
Select Home Warranty
- Free roof coverage
- Frequent discounts
- Slower response times
4.2
$25/mo
Customizable plans
How we picked
Our editorial team scored each provider across more than 30 data points — including pricing, coverage, customer satisfaction, and ease of use. Ratings are weighted to reflect what matters most to real buyers, and we refresh them regularly as products and prices change.